The College Football Playoff committee left Iowa football at No. 15 in its latest rankings released Tuesday night, leapfrogging two three-loss teams over the Hawkeyes despite a weekend of results that seemed to favor them.
Iowa improved to 7-2 with a win over Purdue on Saturday, and other results around the country broke the Hawkeyes' way. Instead of climbing, the Hawkeyes watched Oregon land at No. 13 and Ohio State at No. 14, according to Yahoo Sports.
Why No. 15 falls short of a playoff spot
Being ranked No. 15 sounds close to the 12-team field, but the math is harsher than it looks. One bid in the bracket goes automatically to the highest-ranked Group of Six team, which means Iowa needs to reach at least No. 11 to earn a playoff berth.
That puts four teams between the Hawkeyes and the postseason: No. 11 Wake Forest, No. 10 BYU, No. 9 Tennessee, plus the Ducks and Buckeyes sitting directly ahead. Five teams would all need to lose at least once over the final two weeks of the regular season for Iowa to sneak in.
Ohio State and Oregon raise questions for the committee
Some Hawkeye fans will accept the Buckeyes ranking, since Ohio State routed Iowa at Kinnick Stadium back in October. But that Ohio State team bears little resemblance to the one playing now. Star quarterback Julian Sayin was injured weeks after the Iowa game, and the Buckeyes have looked dreadful since, including two blowout losses before rebounding with a win over Northwestern on Saturday.
The Oregon case is harder to swallow. The Ducks deserve credit for recovering from a 4-3 start, and their win at Ohio State is better than anything on Iowa's resume. But their losses are worse. Oklahoma State, an average Big 12 team at best, dominated the Dante Moore-led Ducks on Sept. 12, and Oregon also fell to Illinois on Oct. 24.
That Illinois loss gives Saturday's game extra weight. Iowa travels to Champaign to face the Fighting Illini, with a chance to post a win over a common opponent and prove to the committee it deserves to move up, as Memesita reported.
A comeback season after the Minnesota loss
Consider where Iowa stood in late October. A dreadful loss to Minnesota on Oct. 24 had most observers writing off the Hawkeyes entirely. Three weeks later, Kirk Ferentz's team is 7-2 and ranked in the top 15, holding a live, if narrow, path to the program's first-ever playoff appearance.
Hawk Central noted that the No. 15 ranking puts Ferentz's squad in position to make its playoff case over the regular season's final three weeks, starting Saturday in Champaign.
What has to happen for Iowa to make the playoff
The road is steep but not closed. Iowa needs to win out, starting with Illinois, and then needs chaos above: losses from Tennessee, BYU, Wake Forest, and at least one of Oregon or Ohio State. Sports Illustrated argued that the committee's refusal to move Iowa after favorable results is the real problem, and the Hawkeyes can only answer on the field.
A win over Illinois would carry double value. It would keep Iowa's record clean down the stretch and hand the committee a head-to-head data point against an Oregon team that lost to the same opponent.
Saturday's game details
Iowa and Illinois meet for the first time in three years when the Hawkeyes travel to Champaign on Saturday afternoon. Kickoff is set for 1:30 p.m. CDT on Big Ten Network.
Quarterback Hank Brown and the Hawkeye offense will face an Illinois defense that has been competitive all season. A win keeps the playoff conversation alive heading into the final two weeks. A loss ends it for good.
Frequently asked questions
Why isn't No. 15 good enough for the College Football Playoff?
The 12-team field reserves one automatic bid for the highest-ranked Group of Six team, so Iowa must be ranked No. 11 or higher to qualify.
Which teams jumped Iowa in the rankings?
Oregon landed at No. 13 and Ohio State at No. 14, both ahead of Iowa despite each carrying three losses.
When does Iowa play Illinois?
Iowa travels to Champaign on Saturday, with kickoff scheduled for 1:30 p.m. CDT on Big Ten Network.
