The Iowa Supreme Court reversed a foreclosure judgment on November 6, 2026, ruling that a Mason City woman who co-owned a home but never signed the promissory note was still a borrower entitled to notice of her right to cure the default. The decision in Newrez LLC, d/b/a Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing v. Lynae D McMillen Dickey Tesdall vacated an Iowa Court of Appeals ruling and sent the case back to district court.
The ruling is a significant win for Iowa homeowners. It confirms that lenders cannot sidestep the state's homestead protections by serving notice on just one co-owner, even when the other co-owner carries no personal liability on the loan.
How the dispute started
According to The Times of India, Lynae D McMillen Dickey Tesdall and Donald S Aegerter bought a house in Mason City in 2019 as joint tenants with rights of survivorship. Wells Fargo Bank provided $260,775 in secured financing for the purchase.
Both were listed as borrowers on the mortgage, but only Aegerter signed the promissory note. Tesdall was not personally responsible for repaying the loan. The mortgage document itself stated that someone who signed the mortgage but not the note was not personally obligated to repay the debt.
Aegerter moved out of the house in November 2021 and relocated to Waterloo. Tesdall stayed in the Mason City home, and the mortgage went into default in June 2022.
Lender refused to give her loan information
Wells Fargo sent notices of the right to cure to Aegerter at both the Mason City property and his Waterloo address. Nothing was sent to Tesdall.
Between July and December 2022, Tesdall repeatedly tried to contact Wells Fargo for information about the overdue payments. Representatives refused to give her details, saying they were not authorized to do so, according to the report. The August 2022 notice sent to Aegerter listed the overdue amount at $6,110.54. Tesdall said in an affidavit that she could have raised enough money to clear the overdue payments if she had been notified.
Wells Fargo filed a foreclosure lawsuit against both co-owners in February 2023, claiming payments had not been made since May 2022 and seeking more than $247,000 in principal, interest and fees. In August 2024, while the case was pending, the bank assigned the mortgage to Newrez LLC, doing business as Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing.
Why the lower courts got it wrong
The district court granted summary judgment for the lender. It reasoned that Tesdall was not entitled to notice because she had not signed the promissory note and was not personally liable. The court also relied on a mortgage provision stating that notice to one borrower counts as notice to all borrowers. The Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed on the same basis, as Justia's opinion summary notes.
The state Supreme Court saw it differently. The justices examined Iowa Code Section 654.2D, which requires lenders foreclosing on a homestead to give borrowers 30 days notice of the right to cure the default before proceeding.
The question, the court held, was whether Tesdall was a borrower on the mortgage, not whether she personally signed the note. Wells Fargo's own document identified her as a borrower. She owned 50% of the property, lived there, and had pledged her ownership interest as security for the financing.
Homestead protections read broadly
The justices emphasized that Iowa's homestead laws are meant to protect homeowners and must be interpreted broadly in their favor. They rejected the lender's argument that notifying one borrower was enough, holding that each borrower entitled to protection must receive the required notice. The court also noted that Aegerter no longer lived at the property while Tesdall continued to occupy it as her home.
Inkl reported that the decision is being described as a landmark ruling requiring notice to a property co-owner before foreclosure actions can proceed.
What happens next
The Supreme Court reversed the district court's judgment, vacated the Court of Appeals decision, and remanded the case for further proceedings. The justices left one question open for the lower court: whether the statutory requirement to prove substantial prejudice applies when a lender fails to provide any notice at all, rather than providing a defective one.
The ruling does not permanently block foreclosure or erase the outstanding mortgage debt. What it establishes is that a co-owner identified as a borrower on a mortgage cannot be denied statutory homestead protections simply because they did not sign the promissory note.
Frequently asked questions
Does a co-owner who did not sign the loan note get foreclosure notice in Iowa?
Yes. The Iowa Supreme Court held on November 6, 2026, that a part-owner and resident of a homestead who signs the mortgage as a borrower is a borrower under Iowa Code Section 654.2D, even if not personally liable on the note, and is entitled to notice of the right to cure before foreclosure.
How long does a borrower have to cure a default in Iowa?
Iowa Code Section 654.2D gives borrowers 30 days from the date the creditor gives the notice to pay overdue installments or otherwise correct the default before foreclosure can proceed.
Does notice to one co-owner count as notice to all?
No, according to the Iowa Supreme Court. Each borrower entitled to protection must receive the required notice, regardless of any mortgage provision saying notice to one borrower counts for all.
