An Iowa listener's question about homes sitting unsold because of homeowners association dues drew a blunt warning from consumer advocate Clark Howard, who told podcast listeners on October 2, 2026, that runaway HOA fees can leave owners unable to sell at all.
Vanessa, an Iowa resident who wrote to The Clark Howard Podcast, noticed homes in her area carrying high HOA fees relative to their value were not moving, and asked whether buying into an association had become, in her words, similar to buying a timeshare. Howard's answer, first reported by Aol, laid out math that every Iowa buyer should understand before signing on a home with association dues.
What Clark Howard told the Iowa listener
Howard pointed to Florida, where condo owners face legally mandated repairs and sharply higher insurance costs passed through their associations.
There are communities in Florida where people can't sell their place because of the homeowners fees.
He added he was not aware of the problem being general nationwide, but the fee pressure Vanessa sees in Iowa is real. Iowa's average HOA fee runs $227 a month, below the national average of roughly $355 a month and far below Florida's $463, according to fee-tracking data drawn from more than 160,000 homeowner reports cited by Aol.
How much a high HOA fee cuts from your sale price
Lenders count HOA dues as part of a buyer's monthly housing cost, so every dollar going to fees is a dollar that cannot go toward the mortgage. That arithmetic shapes offers directly.
Consider a $200,000 home with a $350 monthly fee. That fee consumes 2% of the home's value every year. A nearby comparable home with a $75 fee lets a buyer put far more of the budget toward principal and interest. The $275 monthly gap equals the payment on roughly $43,500 of loan at a 6.5% 30-year rate. A buyer approved for a fixed monthly payment will offer about that much less for the high-fee home, or the seller can wait for a buyer who will not.
Rising fees cost you twice
The direction of the fee after closing matters even more than its starting level. Howard noted that runaway fees usually have something behind them: underfunded reserves, deferred repairs, or ballooning insurance premiums that eventually land in the monthly bill.
Take that same $350 fee over a 10-year hold. If it stays flat, the owner pays $42,000 in total dues. If it rises 10% annually, it reaches roughly $825 a month by year 10, and the cumulative total climbs to about $66,900, an extra $24,900 out of pocket. The bigger hit comes at sale time. By year 10, the rising fee is $475 per month higher than the flat-fee alternative, which at today's rates reduces what the next buyer can offer by roughly $75,000.
That is the timeshare trap Vanessa identified: an obligation you cannot easily price or unload.
Florida shows how bad it can get
The Florida crisis stems from the June 2021 collapse of Champlain Towers South in Surfside, which killed 98 people. State lawmakers responded with Senate Bill 4-D, requiring condo associations in buildings three stories or taller and at least 30 years old to conduct Structural Integrity Reserve Studies and fully fund the reserves those studies identify. Owners can no longer vote to waive contributions. Combined with a hard insurance market, the result has been fee hikes and special assessments running into the tens of thousands of dollars per unit in some South Florida buildings.
The pattern is spreading. Homeowners in one North Carolina neighborhood told WSOC TV they face fees rising to $2,500 and fear liens, bankruptcy, or foreclosure, with some saying they cannot afford to stay and cannot afford to leave.
The housing market makes it worse
Broad market conditions compound the fee problem everywhere. Zillow chief economist Mischa Fisher said in September that mortgage rates above 6.5% were the primary culprit behind weakening sales. Existing home sales ran at a 3.98 million annualized pace in August 2026, then ticked up only slightly to 3.99 million in September, still well below the pace of a year earlier. Contracts signed in September, when the 30-year rate hit 7%, fell to a record low, according to figures reported by Aol through October 20, 2026.
When buyers have more choices than at any point in roughly a decade, the listing with the oversized fee is the first one they skip.
Four checks to run before you make an offer
- Ask the neighbors. This is Howard's free screening test. Ask current residents whether fees have stayed steady or kept rising. If they volunteer a history of hikes and mention another increase coming, he says, that's your fair warning.
- Get the fee history and the reserve study. Request five years of dues from the association and its latest reserve study. Work out the average annual increase. Increases running well above general inflation typically signal deferred repairs that someone, most likely the next buyer, will eventually pay for.
- Calculate the HOA-to-value ratio. Multiply the monthly fee by 12 and divide by the asking price. Compare that ratio with similar listings in the same ZIP code. If your target home is the outlier, the next buyer's agent will notice too, and it will show up as a lower offer.
- Price the fee into your own offer. Enter the monthly HOA fee into a mortgage calculator at current rates to see how much loan it displaces. That figure approximates the discount a future buyer will expect, so build it into what you are willing to pay today.
Communities with stable, well-funded associations stand to hold their value best in a market where every line of the monthly housing cost is under a microscope. For Iowans weighing a home with dues attached, the lesson from Vanessa's question is simple: read the fee history before you fall in love with the house.
FAQ
What is the average HOA fee in Iowa?
Iowa's average HOA fee is $227 a month, below the national average of roughly $355 and Florida's $463, according to fee-tracking data from more than 160,000 homeowner reports.
How much does an HOA fee reduce a home's sale price?
At a 6.5% mortgage rate, a $275 monthly fee gap equals the payment on roughly $43,500 of loan, meaning buyers will offer about that much less for the high-fee home.
Should I avoid buying a home with an HOA?
Not necessarily, but check the fee history, request the reserve study, compare the HOA-to-value ratio with similar listings, and ask neighbors whether dues keep climbing before making an offer.
